|
October 9, 2001
News this month
Baycol withdrawn because of fatal side effects
Bayer Pharmaceuticals has voluntarily withdrawn its cholesterol-lowering
drug cerivastatin, marketed as Baycol®, because of
reports of 31 deaths from rhabdomyolysis. Rhabdomyolysis is a rare
disease in which serious muscle damage results in the release of
muscle cell contents into the blood stream. In rare cases, it may
result in fatal damage to kidneys and other organs.
10 to 15 years of experience with the
other [statins] show that they're safe and that there's something
unique about cerivastatin.
Cholesterol-lowering drugs
Cerivastatin is one of a class of cholesterol-lowering drugs called
statins, which are considered to be the first line of treatment
for most patients with high cholesterol. In addition to cerivastatin,
there are five commonly prescribed statin drugs that block the production
of specific enzymes used by the body to make cholesterol. They are
particularly effective at lowering levels of LDL ("bad") cholesterol
and, to a lesser degree, triglycerides. Studies showed cerivastatin
lowers LDL levels by more than 38 percent.
All of the statin drugs, including lovastatin (Mevacor®),
pravastatin (Pravachol®), simvastatin (Zocor®),
fluvastatin (Lescol®) and atorvastatin (Lipitor®),
have been associated with rare cases of rhabdomyolysis; however,
fatal cases associated with cerivastatin have been significantly
more common than with the other approved statin drugs, according
to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
Sidney Smith, MD, the chief science officer of the American Heart
Association (AHA), says that the 10 to 15 years of experience with
the other drugs show that they're safe and that there's something
unique about cerivastatin.
Those at highest risk
The risk of developing rhabdomyolysis appears to be highest among
older patients as well as those taking high doses of cerivastatin
and those taking the drug in conjunction with another cholesterol-reducing
drug called gemfibrozil. Of the 31 rhabdomyolysis-related deaths
reported in the U.S, 12 were patients who were also taking gemfibrozil.
Two months before withdrawing it from the marketplace, Bayer revised
the label for cerivastatin, specifying that patients should not
receive more than 0.4 milligrams (mg) as the starting dose, regardless
of whether they had taken cholesterol-reducing medications in the
past. In addition to revising the label, Bayer sent a letter to
physicians outlining the changes.
FDA suggests switching to another statin
The FDA suggests patients who had been taking cerivastatin consult
with their physicians about what medications they might substitute.
The agency emphasizes anyone who is taking cerivastatin and experiences
muscle pain or who is also taking gemfibrozil stop taking cerivastatin
immediately.
The benefits of using statins
to manage patients' cholesterol far outweigh the risks of serious
side effects from their use.
Dr. Smith and many other cardiologists are worried that the recall
of cerivastatin might result in patients turning away from statin
drugs in general. Dr. Steven Nissen, who works at the Cleveland
Clinic and serves as a member of the FDA advisory committee, says,
"The statin drugs are among the most important and life-saving drugs
in our armentarium today. In every study that we've done in patients
with coronary heart disease, they reduce the risk of death or recurrent
heart attack by anywhere from 30, 40 percent or greater."
The AHA and the American College of Cardiology (ACC) issued a joint
advisory to reassure people about the effectiveness and safety of
statins. "While statins, like all drugs, have side effects, the
benefits of using statins to manage patients' cholesterol far outweigh
the risks of serious side effects from their use," said ACC President
Douglas P. Zipes, MD. 
Physician Referral Online
A free and confidential service
of Yale-New Haven Hospital.
Physician Referral Online
Using your own criteria, you can request information from a database
of 900 area physicians who have registered to participate.
Request an appointment
We would be happy to assist you in scheduling an appointment with
a member of the hospital's medical staff. Use the link above or
call:
203-688-2000
or toll free
1-888-700-6543
to talk with a referral coordinator.
|
|
Careful monitoring of statin patients
essential
We estimate more than 100 million Americans have total blood
cholesterol levels of 200 milligrams per deciliter (mg/dl) or
higher, and study after study has demonstrated that statin drugs
are the most effective medications we have to lower these numbers.
Statin drugs are the most
effective medications we have to lower [cholesterol] numbers.
Lovastatin (Mevacor), which was the first statin drug approved
by the FDA in 1987, reduced cholesterol levels by 25 percent in
clinical trials. Since then, several major studies have corroborated
the statins' effectiveness in lowering cholesterol and along with
it the risk of dying from heart disease and/or having recurrent
heart attacks.
Push for stronger statins
It's not surprising then there has been an insistent push to develop
stronger statins, and so it has gone. From the introduction of
lovastatin to cerivastatin (Baycol®), the potency
of these drugs has increased, and their effectiveness has increased
as well with some trials reporting LDL cholesterol reductions
of as much as 40 percent and more. But as we have pushed for the
development of stronger statins, it may be possible we're also
pushing the risk-benefit envelope.
Millions take statins
In addition to developing more potent drugs, we've also been prescribing
statins to rapidly escalating numbers of patients because they
are so effective and have few side effects. Clinical trials and
published studies have involved thousands of patients, but millions
now take statins. As the number of users rises, some of whom are
dissimilar from patients participating in the clinical trials,
the possibility of finding serious or lethal side effects does
as well. This is the mathematics of pharmaceuticals and explains
why the FDA maintains post-market surveillance.
As the number of users rises
,
the possibility of finding serious or lethal side effects does
as well.
About 700,000 Americans were taking cerivastatin before the recall,
so it had a relatively low percentage of the statin drug market
share. That's the good news since it is now linked to a higher
risk of dangerous side effects. It was initially approved in the
U.S. in 1997, and it works as all the statins do by blocking a
specific enzyme that's involved in the synthesis of cholesterol.
While all the statins have been associated with a very small
risk of dangerous muscle-destroying side effects, cerivastatin,
particularly when used in combination with other drugs such as
gemfibrozil to lower trigycerides, has a slightly higher risk.
Few side effects
In general, statins have very few side effects. Some patients
experience some gastrointestinal upsets, and in a few cases there
may be some liver abnormalities along with muscle tenderness and
weakness. This can be confusing to patients since newly diagnosed
heart patients often begin new exercise and diet programs and
some of the muscle soreness and weakness can be attributed to
exercise rather than side effects of a statin.
Physician monitoring important
That's why it's so important for physicians to monitor everyone
who begins statin treatment. The incidence of serious muscle injury
and progression to life-threatening rhabdomyolysis is very rare,
but it's essential to report any of the following symptoms to
your doctor immediately:
- Muscle pain, weakness and/or tenderness
- Fever
- Dark urine
- Nausea and/or vomiting
- Malaise (a general feeling of illness or discomfort)
New statin patients should have an initial blood test to evaluate
their blood lipids, liver enzymes and the muscle enzyme CK. They
should then be checked every six to 12 weeks for the first 15
months or so to evaluate the effectiveness of the treatment and
to detect potential liver and muscle problems. If liver enzymes
or CK are elevated, they return to normal within a few weeks of
stopping the drug.
In general, the elderly are more at risk for these side effects,
and they may tolerate smaller doses and less potent statins better.
Also patients who are taking other medications such as gemfibrozil
or cyclosporin need to be particularly carefully monitored.
Lessons learned
What have we learned from our experience with Baycol? In general,
the statins are very safe drugs with a substantial benefit to
heart patients and those at risk for heart disease. Physicians,
however, need to be very careful about who gets them and at what
doses. As the dose increases, so do the side effects. We need
to monitor new patients carefully with lab tests, and we need
to check with patients to ensure they don't begin taking other
medications or supplements that may interact with statins.
Anyone taking statins needs to watch for side effects such as
those we've described. If you experience any of them, call your
doctor right away. Often a change in the kind of statin or dosage
can eliminate the problem quickly. And if you begin taking another
medication, including herbal and other so-called natural supplements,
call your doctor. They can have an effect on your body and how
it reacts to other drugs. 
Dr. Foody is a cardiologist at Yale-New Haven Heart Center
and Yale-New Haven Hospital, as well as an assistant professor
of cardiology at the Yale School of Medicine.
|