|
July 31, 2003
News this month
Trial may widen use of cardiac defibrillators
Recent data from a landmark trial show that implantable cardioverter
defibrillators (ICDs) help prolong the lives of people who have
experienced previous heart attacks.
ICDs help prolong the lives of people
who have experienced previous heart attacks.
Results of the trial, called the Multicenter Automatic Defibrillator
Implantation Trial (MADIT II), demonstrate a 31 percent drop in
the mortality rate among heart attack survivors implanted with ICDs
compared to those receiving medication only.
Dr. Arthur Moss from the University of Rochester who lead the
multicenter trial, said, “To get a 31 percent reduction in
mortality is pretty unusual and dramatic. This study was done in
76 centers, so it was a very representative population of the patients
at risk.
The findings were so dramatic that the trial's independent data
and safety monitoring board stopped the study because of the overwhelming
improvement experienced by those implanted with ICDs.
Study population
Moss and his team of researchers studied 1,232 heart attack survivors
in whom the heart’s ejection fraction—the percentage
of blood in the main muscle-walled chamber that is pumped out when
the chamber contracts—was 30 percent or less.
It usually requires a very large heart attack, or multiple attacks,
to reduce the ejection fraction to this range. People with low ejection
fractions have more severe muscle damage and higher mortality rates
than those with normal ejection fractions. A normal ejection fraction
is between 50 and 75 percent.
Damaged muscle tissue can cause abnormal
heartbeats placing one at risk for sudden cardiac death.
The damaged muscle tissue can cause abnormal heartbeats, or arrhythmias,
placing one at risk for sudden cardiac death. Implanted under the
collarbone like a pacemaker, an ICD can detect irregular and potentially
fatal arrhythmiasknown as ventricular tachycardia or fibrillationand
deliver a shock to restore normal rhythm.
The study participants’ average age was 64 and many had
suffered multiple heart attacks. All received similar medical treatment,
but 742 were randomly assigned to have ICDs implanted in their chests;
490 were not given the devices. Both groups were similar in all
parameters, including the use of beta blockers and ACE inhibitors.
There was a significant 30% reduction
in all causes of mortality in the ICD group.
After two years, there was a significant 30 percent reduction in
all causes of mortality in the ICD group. The pattern continued
over the next four years, when the monitoring board stopped the
study.
The mortality rate among participants with ICDs was 14.2 percent,
compared with 19.8 percent among those without them, according to
results Dr. Moss presented at the 2002 annual meeting of the American
College of Cardiology in Atlanta. The findings were later published
in The New England Journal of Medicine.
Most of the difference in death rates was explained by a reduction
in cardiac arrests caused by abnormal heart rhythms among patients
given the device, Moss said.
Forty-five percent of the deaths in the non-ICD group were caused
by abnormal heart rhythms, compared with 23 percent of the deaths
in the ICD group. In both groups, various complications of heart
disease, especially heart failure, were still the most common causes
of death.
ICD use to widen
The findings have significantly enlarged the population considered
eligible for ICD implantation.
Before the study, FDA guidelines identified about 300,000 Americans
who were eligible each year to receive ICDs. Based on the new findings,
the Medicare Coverage Advisory Committee unanimously voted to recommend
expansion of Medicare coverage for the use of ICDs in patients meeting
the MADIT II criteria.
Dr. Moss estimates that over two million people in the U.S. could
become eligible for implanted devices under these new guidelines.
Physician Referral Online
A free and confidential service
of Yale-New Haven Hospital.
Physician Referral Online
Using your own criteria, you can request information from a database
of 900 area physicians who have registered to participate.
Request an appointment
We would be happy to assist you in scheduling an appointment with
a member of the hospital's medical staff. Use the link above or
call:
203-688-2000
or toll free
1-888-700-6543
to talk with a referral coordinator.
|
|
New hope for heart attack survivors
A sudden unexpected death caused by loss of heart function (cardiac
arrest) is a common cause of death in the U.S., killing more people
than lung cancer, breast cancer and AIDS combined. It is usually
due to a serious fast heart rhythm, called a ventricular tachycardia
or ventricular fibrillation.
Sudden unexpected death caused
by loss of heart function. . . .is usually due to a serious fast
heart rhythm.
A history of heart attacks, coronary artery disease and poor
ejection fractions are all risk factors for sudden cardiac death
(SCD). For many who have survived heart attacks, death can come
quickly and without warning a few years later.
Victims of cardiac arrest often lose consciousness in seconds,
and death follows shortly unless they receive an electric shock
to restore the heart's rhythm within minutes of the event. Approximately
95 percent of these patients who experience an out-of-hospital
cardiac arrest die from the episode.
Preventing sudden cardiac death
To significantly reduce the large number of sudden deaths that
occur annually in the U.S. (about 400,000), it is important to
intervene in high-risk patients prior to the event. That's where
an ICD proves to be a lifesaver. The small oval device jumpstarts
damaged hearts.
The difficulty has been in identifying those at risk for dying
suddenly from those fast heart rhythms. While many studies over
the years have demonstrated the benefits of ICDs in other patient
groups, the MADIT II trial convincingly shows that ICDs make it
possible for people with significant damage to their hearts from
a heart attack, and no prior fast heart rhythms, to live longer
if an ICD is implanted.
How do ICDs work?
When a heart attack occurs, it damages the heart's left ventricle,
the heart's main pumping chamber. The damaged muscle tissue can
cause abnormal heartbeats, or arrhythmias, placing one at risk
for SCD. These abnormal heart rhythms can occur without warning,
many years after the heart attack.
The ICD, like a pacemaker, is implanted under the skin and monitors
the heart's rhythm. When a dangerous rhythm is detected, it rapidly
delivers a controlled electric shock to restore the heart's normal
rhythm.
Know your ejection fraction
If you've had a heart attack, it's important to find out what
your ejection fraction is. This is the measure cardiologists use
to judge how well your heart is pumping. Most people with heart
disease know their cholesterol numbers, but very few are aware
of their ejection fractions.
A normal ejection fraction is at least 50 percent; anything
less indicates a problemit means the heart is pumping out
less than half of the blood into the rest of the bodyand
the heart's effectiveness as a pump is severely impaired. That
person may be at risk for sudden death. In general, the lower
the ejection fraction, the greater the risk of sudden death.
Heart attack survivors should know their ejection fraction,
and those with a low ejection fraction or symptoms of heart failure
(such as shortness of breath or swelling of the legs) should consult
a cardiologist to see whether they might benefit from an ICD.
What's the downside?
Early ICDs were difficult to implant and had limited battery life.
Advances in technology have improved ICDs, making them easier
to implant and safer for patients. They are smaller, much more
complex and have improved battery life from the days of their
inception in 1980 and approval by the Food and Drug Administration
in 1985.
ICDs. . . .should be considered
in all patients with prior heart attacks and significant heart
muscle damage.
During surgery to implant an ICD, fine, insulated wire leads
connected to sthe device are inserted into a vein in the chest
and threaded into the heart muscle. The ICD is implanted under
the skin of the upper chest or the abdomen. The procedure takes
about an hour. Complications are rare and are generally easily
treated.
ICD recipients must see a cardiologist every three to six months
to have the device checked, and ICDs usually need to be replaced
after six to eight years via an outpatient procedure.
The MADIT II trial clearly shows the potential dramatic benefit
of ICDs for a large number of patients. Their use should be considered
in all patients with prior heart attacks and significant heart
muscle damage. They can be implanted with minimal risk and discomfort
and may truly be life saving.
Dr. Grubman is a partner with Cardiology Associates of New
Haven. He is an attending physician at Yale-New Haven Hospital
and a clinical instructor of medicine and cardiology at the Yale
University School of Medicine.
|