|
August 20, 2002
News this month
Results of new pacemaker heartening
A half century of breakthroughs has driven down the percentage
of deaths attributable to cardiovascular disease. Though heart problems
still kill more Americans than any other condition, age-adjusted
rates of death from cardiovascular disease fell about 20 percent
from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s.
The death rate from heart failure has
more than doubled in the last two decades.
This victory has a peculiar twist, however. While the death rate
from heart attacks fell 44 percent over the last two decades, the
death rate from heart failure has more than doubled. Annual deaths
now number about 50,000, and about a million hospitalizations each
year are linked to heart failure.
Heart failure tends to be a disease of the elderly, so the graying
of America is sending the numbers even higher. As the ranks of the
elderly swell, the numbers with the condition are certain to increase.
If you do a good job of keeping people alive, this is where
they end up, said Dr. Ann Bolger, a cardiologist who serves
as a national spokeswoman for the American Heart Association.
New kind of pacemaker resyncs hearts
New research, published in The New England Journal of Medicine
(NEJM) suggests a new kind of pacemaker may be able to relieve symptoms
in some people with heart failure, keeping them out of the hospital.
Biventricular pacemakers synchronize
the left and right sides of the heart.
Biventricular pacemakers have recently been approved for sale by
the federal Food and Drug Administration. Unlike typical pacemakers,
which connect to the upper and lower chambers on the right side
of the heart, this new kind of pacemaker carries a third lead for
the left ventricle, synchronizing the left and right sides of the
heart.
In about one-third of heart failure patients, the walls of the
left ventriclethe heart's main pumping chamberare no
longer synchronized, or pumping together as they normally
would. People with this complication often have worsening of the
symptoms that typically occur with heart failure, which include
fatigue, shortness of breath and swelling of the feet and ankles.
A biventricular pacemaker is designed to resynchronize the pumping
action of the left ventricle and relieve the symptoms of people
with this condition.
Patients who received pacemakers along
with drug treatment reported a better quality of life
Symptoms significantly improved
The NEJM study followed 453 people diagnosed with moderate to severe
heart failure who also had this pumping chamber abnormality. All
were implanted with the pacemakers, but they were turned on in only
228 patients. Both groups were treated with conventional drug therapy.
After six months, the patients who received pacemakers along with
drug treatment reported a better quality of life; and they were
able to walk farther than those treated with drugs alone. Also,
only 8 percent of people in the pacemaker group ended up in the
hospital with worsening heart failure, compared with 15 percent
of those treated with drugs alone.
Getting the heart's chambers to work together results in significant
improvement in symptoms, says the study's lead author William T.
Abraham, MD, of the University of Kentucky College of Medicine.
Cautions
While the results of the study are exciting, doctors
need to be careful when choosing patients for this type of therapy,
wrote Dr. Joshua M. Hare of Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions in
Baltimore, MD, in an editorial accompanying the article. Right
now, what we know about this therapy is that it makes patients feel
better. But they may not need it if symptoms can be controlled with
medication, Hare wrote. We don't yet know if this therapy
helps patients live longer. If future studies show that it does,
then it would be an appropriate first-line treatment for all patients
in this category.
The treatment does have some potential complications, including
a high rate of implantation and maintenance problems. The pacemakers
could not be implanted successfully in 8 percent of people in the
study, and other patients experienced problems after implantation.
The devices are harder to implant than conventional pacemakers because
they have an extra wire that must be fed into a small vein in the
heart. As with any new treatment approach, it's important to weigh
the benefits against potential risks.
Physician Referral Online
A free and confidential service
of Yale-New Haven Hospital.
Physician Referral Online
Using your own criteria, you can request information from a database
of 900 area physicians who have registered to participate.
Request an appointment
We would be happy to assist you in scheduling an appointment with
a member of the hospital's medical staff. Use the link above or
call:
203-688-2000
or toll free
1-888-700-6543
to talk with a referral coordinator.
|
|
More effective treatment options for
heart failure patients
It's possible the number of heart failure patients in the country
may double to 10 million in less than a decade. The disease is
approaching epidemic proportions. People who in the past would
have died from heart attacks are now often being treated with
drugs and surgery and continue to live for many years. But damage
from the heart attack and the underlying conditions that contribute
to heart disease, such as high blood pressure and atherosclerosis,
persist, weakening the heart's function and compromising an individual's
quality of life.
The number of heart failure
patients. . .may double to 10 million in less than a decade.
Fortunately, better treatments are appearing across the spectrum
of the condition, from those at risk of developing the disease
to those for whom a heart transplant appears the best choice.
For decades, we had few effective options for dealing with heart
failure, other than to make people as comfortable as possible
during their inevitable decline.
There is still no known cure, but we have an ever-increasing
number of treatment options to minimize symptoms and slow the
progression of the disease. The combination of lifestyle changes
and drug therapythe foundation of almost all heart failure
treatment regimenscan markedly improve both survival rates
and quality of life.
Treatment options
Treatment varies according to the stage of heart failure and each
individual's specific medical history. We counsel most patients
to make adjustments in their lifestyle, including stopping smoking,
reducing consumption of salt and saturated fat and increasing
exercise. We also prescribe a variety of medications depending
on the stage of the disease.
Old standbys for high blood pressure treatment, such as beta
blockers and ACE inhibitors, have found new roles for heart failure
patients. These have joined traditional treatments including diuretics
and digoxin, an age-old drug that helps the heart beat more forcefully.
Biventricular pacemakers
are
designed to induce a failing heart into beating more effectively.
If medications do not adequately enhance heart function, however,
certain patients with advanced heart failure may become candidates
for other interventions, including surgery and implantable devices.
Resychronization pacemakers
Last year, the FDA approved a special kind of device, known as
resynchronization or biventricular pacemakers, which are designed
to induce a failing heart into beating more effectively. The pacemakers
work by delivering an electrical pulse to prod the heart's ventricles
into beating simultaneously, as they do in undamaged hearts. These
devices are designed to work in patients with a specific electrocardiogram
abnormality called intraventricular conduction delay
(IVCD). Approximately one third of patients with heart failure
have IVCD.
Though expensive, about $10,000, those devices have quickly
found a place in the arsenal of heart failure experts looking
for effective ways to treat the third of patients whose heart
chambers fail to pump together. As the recent study published
in The New England Journal of Medicine shows, these implanted
devices have an immediate impact on the quality of life of some
patients who have not been responsive to drug therapyimproved
energy, less shortness of breath, fewer hospitalizations.
Those with pacemakers were
able to exercise harder and walk farther than those treated with
medication alone.
By the end of the study, it was clear that patients with the
pacemaker did better than those treated with medication alone.
Among those whose pacemaker was not turned on, 34 required hospitalization
for worsening heart failure, compared to 18 in the pacemaker group.
Those with pacemakers were able to exercise harder and walk farther
than those treated with medication alone. And those in the pacemaker
group reported a much higher quality of life than those who received
medication alone.
The devices, like drug therapy, appear to reduce costs long-term
by keeping patients out of the hospital. We do not yet know if
these devices will result in prolonging a patient's life. Currently,
only about 50 percent of patients with heart failure live for
another five years after their diagnosis.
In addition, the patients implanted with the new devices run
the risk of implantation and maintenance problems. In about 8
percent of the patients in the study, the pacemakers could not
be implanted successfully; other patients experienced problems
after implantation. The benefits are significant however, and
I would suggest any heart failure patients discuss this option
with their physicians to determine if they are appropriate candidates.
Dr. Katz is the director of the Yale Cardiomyopathy Program.
He is a cardiologist at Yale-New Haven Heart Center and Yale-New
Haven Hospital, as well as an associate professor of internal
medicine in the cardiovascular medicine section at the Yale School
of Medicine.
|