A small but promising study
Although the study was very small and it was preliminary, the results are
optimistic for patients with Parkinson’s Disease and other degenerative
brain diseases because it showed that the method of treatment did no harm.
The fact that the 12 patients showed improvement in motor coordination for as
long as a year after the genes were injected into the region of their brains
called the subthalamic nucleus was the icing on the cake.
Study looked only at safety
The study was a Phase 1 study, meaning it was designed to test the safety of
the method. It succeeded in showing that the virus used as the delivery
device, an adeno-associated virus called AAV2, and the gene that spurs the
subthalamic cells to make GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid), a chemical that
calms overexcited nerve pathways, did not cause any side effects, such as
infections or adverse immune system reactions. The treatment and method are
safe.
Better treatment methods sought
The study’s authors have said they plan to launch a much larger, Phase
2 trial in which they will determine how effective the treatment is. This
study opens the door for that to happen. In addition, the research benefits
studies using the same or similar virus vectors, and those targeting other
areas of the brain with other genes. The pioneers of any study are
responsible for showing the largest amount of safety data, and the lead
researchers did just that.
'The research benefits other
studies using the same or
similar virus vectors,
and those targeting other
areas of the brain with
other genes.'
This research is important because the available Parkinson’s
treatments do not cure the disease; they only dampen the symptoms. A number
of drugs lessen the tremors and rigidity, among them, L-dopa, which replaces
the dopamine in cells that are still functioning normally. But drugs often
lose their effectiveness over time. Increased doses of L-dopa, for example,
are often associated with dyskinesias, or involuntary uncontrolled movement.
In fact, patients are instructed to take “drug holidays” on a
regular schedule to prolong the effectiveness of the medications. And once a
critical number of the brain’s dopamine-producing cells die, the
medication becomes completely ineffective.
Electric pulses
Deep brain stimulation is a widely used treatment that targets thalamus or
the subthalamic nucleus, the same area of the brain Kaplitt and
During’s study did. A pacemaker-like device implanted in the brain
sends electric pulses to the subthalamic nucleus that calm the overactive
firings of neurons. But it has not clearly been demonstrated that deep brain
stimulation slows the progress of Parkinson’s. In addition, deep brain
stimulation carries the risk of infection associated with any implant, as
well as other negatives, such as the need for frequent tuning.
That’s why gene therapy that tweaks the brain’s chemistry and
regulatory behavior holds a lot of promise. A solid first step of research A
randomized, controlled, doubleblinded study is the best way for researchers
to determine whether they are doing something good. It may turn out that the
answer to Parkinson’s is some combination of cell therapy – such
as replacing the dopamine-producing cells – and gene therapy. This
study is just the first step of many. But it is a encouraging and solid first
step.
Dr. Kenneth Vives is chief of stereotactic and functional neurosurgery
in the department of neurosurgery at Yale School of Medicine.