Click here for YNHH home page.

Sign up for HealthLINK.

Can we help?

Follow up on this month's He@lthLINK

 


Phone Numbers

Directory assistance
(203) 688-4242

Patient information
(203) 688-4177

Adult emergency
(203) 688-2222

Children's emergency
(203) 688-3333

Admitting
(203) 688-2221

Children's admitting
(203) 688-3331



Mailing address:
Yale-New Haven Hospital
20 York Street
New Haven, CT
06510-3202





Yale-New Haven Hospital, New Haven, Connecticut, USA HealthLINK: Women's Health
July 19, 1999

News this month
Stillbirth experience may heighten anxiety and depression in subsequent pregnancy

Researchers at St. George’s Hospital Medical School in London reported women who became pregnant within 12 months following stillbirths had higher levels of depression and anxiety than women who waited for 12 months or more before conceiving again. The results were reported in the June 26 issue of the British Medical Journal.

A team led by Dr. P. M. Hughes compared the experience of 60 pregnant women whose earlier pregnancies had ended in stillbirth after 18 weeks’ gestation with 60 women who were pregnant for the first time.

“. . .there may be an advantage in waiting 12 months before the next conception.”

Investigators report depression scores of 10.8 in women who had experienced previous stillbirths compared to a score of 8.2 in the control group of women who had not experienced loss. Anxiety scores were also higher, 39.8 in women with prior stillbirths, compared with 32.8 in the control group. These differences in depression and anxiety scores, according to the investigators, were accounted for by women who became pregnant less than 12 months following their stillbirths. These women were also more depressed and anxious (19 percent) one year after giving birth to live babies than the control group (8 percent).

Reasons for the difference
Dr. Hughes and colleagues report women who have experienced recent stillbirths might “understandably still [be] grieving” by the time they reach the third trimester of their second pregnancy. However, “…most women who went ahead quickly with another pregnancy did not experience high levels of anxiety and depression, and for some parents other considerations may outweigh the possible higher risk of psychological symptoms.”

Personality might be another factor, according to Hughes. “The lower anxiety scores of women who did not conceive within 12 months suggests either they are less anxious than those who did conceive or the longer mourning process lessened their anxiety.”

The investigators concluded that because high levels of anxiety and depression during and after pregnancy may be associated with potential problems for both the mother and the infant, “…there may be an advantage in waiting 12 months before the next conception.”

Key messages

  • Women whose previous pregnancy ended in stillbirth had significantly higher levels of depression and anxiety during their subsequent pregnancy than those who had not experienced loss.
  • Those who had conceived over 12 months after stillbirth were, however, similar to the control group at all points and had lower anxiety a year after the next birth.
  • Women who conceived within 12 months after loss had a significantly higher risk of heightened anxiety during the next pregnancy and of depression 12 months postpartum than women who conceived later after loss.
  • Women may need a year to mourn the lost child before beginning another pregnancy, or women who chose to conceive sooner may be intrinsically more vulnerable to depression and anxiety.
  • Parents have various and individual reasons for timing the next pregnancy, but there may be advantage in waiting 12 months before conception.

Read the entire paper.

Physician Referral Online

A free and confidential service
of Yale-New Haven Hospital.

Physician Referral Online
Using your own criteria, you can request information from a database of 900 area physicians who have registered to participate.

Request an appointment
We would be happy to assist you in scheduling an appointment with a member of the hospital's medical staff. Use the link above or call:

203-688-2000
or toll free
1-888-700-6543
to talk with a referral coordinator.


David Olive, M.D.

Neonatal loss: grieving and recovery

The question of whether women and their partners should wait a year to conceive after the loss of a pregnancy is a complicated one. Dr. Hughes and his colleagues’ study suggests there may be some benefit to waiting a year, but each family needs to consider their individual situation and talk with their caregivers about what makes the most sense for them.

My experience has been that many families may choose to wait a year or more to get pregnant after delivering a stillborn child. Each pregnancy is accompanied by hopes, dreams and wishes that end with the loss of a child. Families may need time to deal with the fear and anxiety that accompany such a loss and to mourn the death of that child. Grieving is not easy, it is often long, unpredictable and requires a lot of energy. Parents and family members need time to work through this pain toward healing.

Families may need time to deal with the fear and anxiety that accompany loss and to mourn the death of a child.

Conversely, some families are anxious to begin another pregnancy quickly. We are seeing more women beginning their families at a later age, and those families must weigh the need to wait with the potential diminishing of fertility. And many of my patients who have a miscarriage early in their pregnancy decide to wait a couple of months and then begin trying to conceive again.

These decisions are personal ones and are best made on an individual basis. The Hughes’ study recognizes that fact and acknowledges that many families have considerations that outweigh the possible higher risk of psychological symptoms.

Grieving process
Although the optimal timing of a subsequent pregnancy varies with each family, the importance of grieving for a pregnancy loss is unequivocal whether that loss occurs a few weeks after conception or at term.

As recently as the early 1980s, it was common practice to whisk away a stillborn child before the parents saw the child or had a chance to hold it in an effort to spare them pain. Stillborn babies were often quickly buried in unmarked graves, and parents had few ways to express their feelings of loss and grief.

It is not unusual for women to be depressed after a pregnancy loss.

We now have a better understanding of how important it is for everyone to acknowledge the loss. When a woman delivers a stillborn child today, it is likely she and her family will have an opportunity to see and hold the child. They may be encouraged to have a memorial service or funeral for the child. At Yale-New Haven Hospital, clergy are available and specially trained bereavement nurses counsel the family and prepare memory boxes with the child’s bracelet, blanket, photos and footprints.

It is not unusual for women to be depressed after a pregnancy loss. My experience has been symptoms are more severe with full-term losses, but recognition of grief must be acknowledged in even the earliest of pregnancy losses. The symptoms of depression may range from severe postpartum depression and suicidal thoughts, to sleep disturbances, to withdrawal from family and friends, eating disorders and feelings of hopelessness. She and her family need time to express their fears, share their grief and come to terms with their loss. Taking time to go through this process may take some families longer than others, and I often suggest counseling to my patients or participation in bereavement support groups.

Hygeia, a sharing site for families
In 1995, I launched a web site (www.hygeia.org) to provide a place for grieving families to express their pain and share the stories of their losses. Since that time, more than 70,000 families have visited the site, which includes poetry and stories about neonatal loss as well as medical information written by caregivers. More than 4,000 families have registered so they might share their stories with others.

Parents and family members will not forget about the child they lost after a month or a year, but encouraging them to express their feelings and concerns can help them work through this painful experience and may help prepare them for a less stressful subsequent pregnancy.


Dr. Berman is an attending obstetrician/gynecologist at Yale-New Haven Hospital and a clinical professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the Yale School of Medicine. He is president of the County Obstetrics and Gynecology Group with offices in New Haven, Branford, Clinton and Wallingford and founder of the Hygeia® Foundation for Perinatal Loss and Bereavement.


Spacer.
Subscribe to HealthLink.

 

Other related links.
Home page
Staff directory
Directions and parking
Online resources
Yale New Haven Health System
  Need a doctor?
Search
Comments
Top of page